Cast card: Johnny Bananas
- Show
- The Challenge
- Franchise
- The Real World and The Challenge
- Network
- MTV
- Debut
- 2006Real World: Key West
- Role
- Winner
- Born
- June 22, 1982 (age 44)
- Hometown
- Fullerton, California
- Known for
- Seven-time Challenge champion
- Also known as
- Johnny Devenanzio, John Devenanzio, Bananas
By Realitydle · Sources and corrections
Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio has spent two decades as The Challenge's most famous competitor and one of its most polarizing players. He has won seven seasons, and his choice to keep an entire $275,000 prize for himself in 2016 remains one of the most debated finales in the show's history.
Connected guides: CT Tamburello (Longtime rival), Wes Bergmann (Rival), Evelyn Smith (The Island and Rivals co-champion), Cara Maria Sorbello (Castmate), and Mark Long (Castmate).
Who is Johnny Bananas?
John Amadeus Devenanzio was born on June 22, 1982, in Fullerton, California. He was a recent Pennsylvania State University graduate when MTV cast him on The Real World, and his casting made headlines in the campus newspaper.
The Real World: Key West premiered on February 28, 2006, and it was during that season that he became known as Johnny Bananas. Later that year he joined his first Challenge season, The Duel, and was eliminated in its first episode, the start of a career that has now run for two decades.
Johnny Bananas on The Challenge
Bananas was runner-up on The Inferno 3 in 2007 and broke through with back-to-back wins on The Island in 2008 and The Ruins in 2009. He added titles on Rivals in 2011 with Tyler Duckworth, Battle of the Exes in 2012 with Camila Nakagawa, and Free Agents in 2014. His sixth win, on Rivals III in 2016, came with a twist: the partner with the most points in the final could keep all the money or share it, and Bananas kept the full $275,000 instead of splitting it with Sarah Rice. His seventh title came on Total Madness in 2020, and he also won the first season of the spin-off Champs vs. Stars.
His losses are part of the legend too. On Cutthroat in 2010 he was sent into a Gulag elimination against CT Tamburello, brought back as a Heavy Hitter, with the two strapped back to back, and CT carried him across the arena on his back; Bananas lost and went home. He finished second on Rivals II in 2013 and Ride or Dies in 2023, third on Battle of the Eras, which ended in 2025, and reached the Final Challenge of season 42, Cutthroat, whose finale began airing on October 21, 2026.
Beyond The Challenge
Bananas hosted NBC's lifestyle series 1st Look from 2018 to 2023 and has appeared on a long list of other competitions. He finished third on CBS's The Challenge: USA 2 in 2023, played The Challenge: World Championship on Paramount+ the same year, and was runner-up on the first season of E!'s House of Villains.
He joined the second season of Peacock's The Traitors in 2024 but was murdered in episode 2. He was also runner-up on season 19 of Food Network's Worst Cooks in America in 2020.
Personal life
After filming season 33, Bananas began dating castmate Morgan Willett, the winner of Big Brother: Over the Top. The couple split in September 2021. He was previously in a relationship with Olympic snowboarding champion Hannah Teter.
His long rivalry with CT Tamburello, which boiled over on Cutthroat in 2010, remains one of the franchise's defining storylines; the two later won Champs vs. Stars on the same team and both made the Final Challenge of season 42.
Career
Reality TV career
| Show | Years | Role |
|---|---|---|
| The Real WorldKey West | 2006 | Main cast |
| The Challenge24 seasons, The Duel to Cutthroat | 2006-present | Seven-time winner |
| The Challenge: Champs vs. StarsSeason 1 | 2017-2018 | Winner |
| 1st LookNBC series | 2018-2023 | Host |
| Worst Cooks in AmericaSeason 19 | 2020 | Runner-up |
| The Challenge: World ChampionshipSeason 1 | 2023 | Eliminated |
| The Challenge: USASeason 2 | 2023 | 3rd place |
| House of VillainsSeason 1 | 2023 | Runner-up |
| The TraitorsSeason 2 | 2024 | Faithful, murdered in episode 2 |
Previously on Challenge
Defining moments
2009The Ruins
Back-to-back titles
A year after winning The Island, he wins The Ruins and becomes the show's leading champion of his era.
2010Cutthroat
Strapped to CT
Sent into the Gulag against Heavy Hitter CT Tamburello while strapped back to back, he ends up carried on CT's back and is eliminated.
2016Rivals III · "Split Decision"
Keeping the $275,000
With the most points in the final, he chooses to keep the entire first-place prize rather than share it with partner Sarah Rice.
2020Total Madness
Win number seven
He is crowned the male champion of Total Madness, alongside female winner Jenny West, extending his record to seven titles.
Test yourself
Johnny Bananas quiz: 5 questions
Think of your answer, then open the reveal to check it. New to the clues? See how to play.
Question 1
Which competitor became the first to win seven Challenge championships, clinching number seven on Total Madness in 2020?
- Johnny Bananas
- CT Tamburello
- Darrell Taylor
- Jordan Wiseley
Show the answer
Answer: A. Johnny Bananas
Johnny Bananas took his seventh title on Total Madness in 2020, twelve years after his first win on The Island in 2008.
From our The Challenge Trivia.
Question 2
On Rivals III, Johnny Bananas famously kept the entire $275,000 prize instead of splitting it with which partner?
- Camila Nakagawa
- Sarah Rice
- Laurel Stucky
- Jenny West
Show the answer
Answer: B. Sarah Rice
Bananas and Sarah Rice won Rivals III together in 2016, and he chose to keep all the money in the final twist. Sarah had voted him into an elimination on an earlier season.
From our The Challenge Trivia.
Question 3
Which show is Johnny Bananas best known for?
- Dancing with the Stars
- Love & Hip Hop: New York
- The Challenge
- The Real Housewives of New York City
Show the answer
Answer: C. The Challenge
Johnny Bananas is best known for The Challenge, part of The Real World and The Challenge.
Question 4
In what year did Johnny Bananas first appear on screen in the The Real World and The Challenge franchise?
- 2003
- 2002
- 2008
- 2006
Show the answer
Answer: D. 2006
Johnny Bananas debuted in 2006 (Real World: Key West). That is the Debut clue on the Realitydle board.
Question 5
Which network aired Johnny Bananas's debut season?
- MTV
- History
- VH1
- A&E
Show the answer
Answer: A. MTV
Johnny Bananas's debut season aired on MTV, so MTV is the Network clue for Johnny Bananas.
Asked and answered
Johnny Bananas: frequently asked questions
How old is Johnny Bananas?
Johnny Bananas was born on June 22, 1982, and is 44 years old as of November 2026.
How many times has Johnny Bananas won The Challenge?
He has won seven main seasons: The Island, The Ruins, Rivals, Battle of the Exes, Free Agents, Rivals III, and Total Madness. He also won the spin-off Champs vs. Stars.
What did Johnny Bananas do to Sarah Rice?
In the Rivals III final in 2016, the partner with the most points could keep the $275,000 prize or share it. Bananas had the most points and kept all of the money instead of splitting it with Sarah Rice.
What was Johnny Bananas' first show?
He debuted on MTV's The Real World: Key West, which premiered in February 2006. His first Challenge season was The Duel later that year.
Is Johnny Bananas on the new season of The Challenge?
Yes. He is in the cast of season 42, The Challenge: Cutthroat, which premiered on Paramount+ on August 5, 2026, and he made it to the season's Final Challenge, which began airing in October 2026.
Was Johnny Bananas on The Traitors?
Yes. He played season two of The Traitors in 2024 as a Faithful and was murdered in episode 2.
Sources and corrections
Reference pages used for this guide. Relationships and careers can change; consult the linked sources for their reporting dates.
- Johnny Devenanzio, Wikipedia
- The Real World: Key West, Wikipedia
- List of The Challenge (TV series) contestants, Wikipedia
- The Challenge: Rivals III, Wikipedia
- The Challenge: Cutthroat (2010 season), Wikipedia
- The Challenge: Cutthroat (2026 season), Wikipedia
- The Traitors (American TV series) season 2, Wikipedia
Connections
Johnny Bananas's castmates and connections
- CT TamburelloLongtime rival · Debut 2003Five-time Challenge champion from Real World: Paris
- Wes BergmannRival · Debut 2005Three-time Challenge champion from Real World: Austin
- Evelyn SmithThe Island and Rivals co-champion · Debut 2006Three-time Challenge champion from Fresh Meat
- Cara Maria SorbelloCastmate · Debut 2010Two-time Challenge champion from Fresh Meat II
- Mark LongCastmate · Debut 1995Original Road Rules star and two-time Challenge winner
Meet the full cast of The ChallengeStars who debuted in the 2000s