Cast card: Evelyn Smith
- Show
- The Challenge
- Franchise
- The Real World and The Challenge
- Network
- MTV
- Debut
- 2006The Challenge: Fresh Meat
- Role
- Winner
- Born
- About 1987 (age about 39)
- Known for
- Three-time Challenge champion from Fresh Meat
By Realitydle · Sources and corrections
Evelyn Smith was one of the first true rookies The Challenge ever cast, and within two years she was one of its most feared women. She won three of the seven seasons she played, then left at the height of her run.
Connected guides: Johnny Bananas (The Island and Rivals co-champion), Wes Bergmann (Castmate), Cara Maria Sorbello (Rivals castmate), CT Tamburello (Castmate), and Mark Long (Challenge castmate).
Who is Evelyn Smith?
Evelyn Smith, a New York native, was fresh out of high school when MTV cast her on Fresh Meat, the 12th season of The Challenge and the first to pair veterans of The Real World and Road Rules with newcomers who had never been on either show. A standout softball player, she took the spot instead of starting at the University of Arizona on a softball scholarship.
Fresh Meat premiered on May 29, 2006, and was filmed in Australia. In the draft, Real World: Austin's Danny Jamieson took Evelyn with the first pick, but the pair were the first team eliminated, in episode 2.
Evelyn Smith on The Challenge
Her second season changed everything. On The Inferno 3 in 2007, filmed in Cape Town, South Africa, she played on the Bad Asses team that won the final. She was runner-up on The Gauntlet III in early 2008, then won The Island later that year, a season set on an island off the coast of Panama where the cast built boats and raced them to a buried treasure.
After a quick exit from The Ruins in 2009, she joined Fresh Meat II in 2010 as a replacement, partnered with Luke Wolfe, and the pair won two eliminations before going home in episode 9. She returned for Rivals in 2011, which paired players with someone they had clashed with, and she and Paula Meronek won the women's side, giving Evelyn her third title in seven seasons. Rivals was her last season.
Life after The Challenge
Evelyn stepped away from the show to finish her education, graduating summa cum laude from the University of San Diego in 2013 with a degree in history and membership in Phi Beta Kappa. She later earned a law degree from Harvard Law School.
Since then she has worked in politics and public policy, including on Kirsten Gillibrand's and Pete Buttigieg's campaigns for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination, and she has not returned to The Challenge or its All Stars spin-off.
Career
Reality TV career
| Show | Years | Role |
|---|---|---|
| The ChallengeFresh Meat | 2006 | Eliminated in episode 2 |
| The ChallengeThe Inferno 3 | 2007 | Winner |
| The ChallengeThe Gauntlet III | 2008 | Runner-up |
| The ChallengeThe Island | 2008 | Winner |
| The ChallengeThe Ruins | 2009 | Eliminated |
| The ChallengeFresh Meat II | 2010 | Eliminated in episode 9 |
| The ChallengeRivals | 2011 | Winner |
Previously on Challenge
Defining moments
2006Fresh Meat
First pick in the draft
Danny Jamieson chooses her first among the rookies, though the pair become the season's first team eliminated.
2007The Inferno 3
Bad Asses win The Inferno 3
In only her second season she wins her first title as part of the victorious Bad Asses team.
2008The Island
Treasure on The Island
She earns a key to the final boat race and is among the four winners who reach the buried treasure.
2011Rivals
Rivals champion
Paired with Paula Meronek, she wins the women's side for her third title in her final season.
Test yourself
Evelyn Smith quiz: 5 questions
Think of your answer, then open the reveal to check it. New to the clues? See how to play.
Question 1
Evelyn Smith was among the winners of The Island in 2008, a season borrowing ideas from which other show?
- Survivor
- Big Brother
- The Amazing Race
- Fear Factor
Show the answer
Answer: A. Survivor
Players on The Island had to work for their own food and shelter, much like on Survivor, and formed their own alliances instead of preset teams. Evelyn shared the win with Derrick Kosinski, Johnny Bananas and Kenny Santucci.
From our The Challenge Trivia.
Question 2
Which show is Evelyn Smith best known for?
- Sister Wives
- The Challenge
- Top Chef
- The Real Housewives of New York City
Show the answer
Answer: B. The Challenge
Evelyn Smith is best known for The Challenge, part of The Real World and The Challenge.
Question 3
In what year did Evelyn Smith first appear on screen in the The Real World and The Challenge franchise?
- 2010
- 2009
- 2000
- 2006
Show the answer
Answer: D. 2006
Evelyn Smith debuted in 2006 (The Challenge: Fresh Meat). That is the Debut clue on the Realitydle board.
Question 4
Which network aired Evelyn Smith's debut season?
- MTV
- CBS
- Netflix
- HGTV
Show the answer
Answer: A. MTV
Evelyn Smith's debut season aired on MTV, so MTV is the Network clue for Evelyn Smith.
Question 5
Which role does Evelyn Smith play on the Realitydle board?
- Contestant
- Host or judge
- Cast member
- Winner
Show the answer
Answer: D. Winner
Evelyn Smith counts as a winner on The Challenge. Winner, Finalist, and Contestant are for stars who competed; Lead, Cast, and Host cover everyone else.
Asked and answered
Evelyn Smith: frequently asked questions
How old is Evelyn Smith?
Evelyn Smith was born in about 1987 and is about 39 years old as of November 2026.
How many times did Evelyn Smith win The Challenge?
Three times: The Inferno 3 in 2007, The Island in 2008, and Rivals in 2011 with Paula Meronek.
What season was Evelyn Smith first on?
She debuted on Fresh Meat, the 12th season of The Challenge, which premiered in May 2006. She was a rookie partnered with Danny Jamieson.
Who was Evelyn's partner on Rivals?
Paula Meronek of The Real World: Key West. The two won the women's side of Rivals in 2011.
What is Evelyn Smith from The Challenge doing now?
She left reality TV after Rivals in 2011, graduated from the University of San Diego in 2013, earned a degree from Harvard Law School, and has worked on Democratic political campaigns and in public policy.
Sources and corrections
Reference pages used for this guide. Relationships and careers can change; consult the linked sources for their reporting dates.
Connections
Evelyn Smith's castmates and connections
- Johnny BananasThe Island and Rivals co-champion · Debut 2006Seven-time Challenge champion
- Wes BergmannCastmate · Debut 2005Three-time Challenge champion from Real World: Austin
- Cara Maria SorbelloRivals castmate · Debut 2010Two-time Challenge champion from Fresh Meat II
- CT TamburelloCastmate · Debut 2003Five-time Challenge champion from Real World: Paris
Up next
More from The Challenge
Meet the full cast of The ChallengeStars who debuted in the 2000s